CEPII, Recherche et Expertise sur l'economie mondiale
Border Apprehensions and Federal Sentencing of Hispanic Citizens in the United States


Simone Bertoli
Morgane Laouenan
Jérôme Valette

 Highlights :
  • Hispanic citizens receive significantly longer sentences than non-Hispanic citizens in the Federal Criminal Justice System in the United States.
  • This gap in sentencing is time-variant and directly correlated with apprehensions of illegal aliens at the US- Mexico border.
  • Apprehensions can increase the salience of Hispanic ethnic identity, which is associated with persistent negative stereotypes, and can also deteriorate attitudes toward Hispanics.

 Abstract :
We provide evidence that Hispanic citizens receive significantly longer sentences than non-Hispanic citizens in the Federal Criminal Justice System in the United States when a higher number of illegal aliens are apprehended along the southwest border. Apprehensions can increase the salience of Hispanic ethnic identity, which is associated with persistent negative stereotypes, and can also deteriorate attitudes toward Hispanics. We rule out concerns that apprehensions might convey legally relevant information to judges. Thus, we provide direct evidence for time-varying discrimination toward Hispanic defendants. Our estimated effect is only at play for defendants without a heavy previous criminal record.

 Keywords : Immigration | Ethnic Identity | Discrimination | Attitudes | Salience | Sentences

 JEL : K42, J15, F22


Related articles and documents :

  • "Border Apprehensions and Hispanic Sentences in the US Federal Criminal Justice System", The Journal of Law & Economics

  • CEPII Working Paper
    N°2023-02, January 2023

    Full text

    Reference
    BibTeX (with abstract),
    plain text (with abstract),
    RIS (with abstract)

    Contact: 
     Fields of expertise

    Migrations
    Back